|QUOTE (Evolution @ Aug 22 2008, 03:51 PM)|
| Skimpy feedback?|
Did we or did we not grade and critique them?
Bleh. I'll take my 3..
|QUOTE (Evolution @ Aug 18 2008, 08:28 PM)|
| Looks 1.25/2|
|QUOTE (helberg19 @ Aug 17 2008, 09:37 PM)|
| Looks (1.25/2): I don't like how this one looks being outside of the border. The logo on the duplication of the player stands out too much. The text is...weird. The border looks alright, everything seems to look good together. Another issue is with the white parts of the jersey, you should have done the JC around them, that would have looked much better.|
Effort/Originality (1.5/2): BG looks pretty simple, not many effects seen, such as lighting. Could have gotten rid of the eagles on the shoulders, and done the JC aroundt he numbers and the white parts.
|QUOTE (Mvick07 @ Aug 17 2008, 09:40 PM)|
| Looks 1.25/2 - I like this sig alot. I would have liked to have seen a different background or border. Cuz it seems like you always use the same kind of ones for all of your work. I think you did a great job on the JC and HC though. Besides the eagle on both shoulders and the bc logo on the neck. That is the best JC/HC i have seen in my life.|
Effort 1.5/2 - You put in your custom signature Background. Did a JC, HC, and like he said had the Facemask Change. But you forgot to change the BC logo on the NECK. thats what brought you down a little bit
|QUOTE (captobvious @ Aug 22 2008, 08:21 PM)|
| 4 points|
Good job of getting all (or nearly all) of the graphics graded. Most of your grades were skimpy on the feedback.
Same as above, and missed two graphics.
I can't see giving any points for just one or two grades.
|QUOTE (playmaker @ Aug 22 2008, 09:44 PM)|
| Looks .75/4|
More a graphic than a sig which is fine but it doesn't look all great. JC is ok but its just plain black would've been better to add a nice BG or a stripe on jersey. HC looks weird
There is definitely some effort thrown into this but not a whole lot, just a JC and HC thrown on a black background
BG is uggggly, Cut is choppy looking. Text is meh best you could probably do with paint, HC is ok
It probably took you 30 seconds to find that BG, same with text. Good try on the HC but that's about it
I don't really like it very much but it's decent. There's way too much stuff going on and it's a process to look through all of it.
Although it doesn't look great, the effort is shown in this sig, Multiple cuts and a nice bg
|QUOTE (camo0309 @ Aug 22 2008, 01:53 PM)|
|for one u took points off of my graphic because i made it before i got traded, and didnt save a psd|
|QUOTE (playmaker @ Aug 22 2008, 06:21 PM)|
|and ididnt take off points actually i was just telling u|